I started this blog post with the notion that I could think of a topic that I believe is worthy enough to be documented. I soon became stumped, and have now decided that it would be more beneficial to analyze the documents I have seen, and consider the reasons why they were successful to me.
From the documentaries I have seen, there seems to be certain kinds that make the “real world” stories stand out. To consider this I first looked at the documentaries Supersize Me, and The Cove. Both of these revolve around topics I was not familiar with. This fact alone won me over as a viewer. I immediately became interested in these stories because they were new to me. The “real world” stories of dolphin slaughtering and over consumption of McDonalds stand out because as a viewer you feel like you are discovering this topic by yourself. It’s new to you, and you know it’s real. This gives you almost a sense of ownership.
Another kind of documentaries that I have found makes them stand out is the idea that you have seen this “real world” story in a Hollywood movie. The one documentary I have seen that really exemplifies this is Buck. It is about Buck Brannaman and his successful career at training and taming horses. The connection I made to this was with the move Seabiscuit. The one thing that stuck with me from the movie was of course the relationship between Tobey McGuire’s character, Red and Seabiscuit. It made me happy, and sad, and most of all hopeful that there are real horse owners/jockeys that care as much as Red did. The reason why I think Buck stood out so much is because it was taking the drama and Hollywood spin of the relationship of a horse and it’s owner, and making it real. Buck provided me with proof. In my experience, when I can relate the “real world” stories I have seen to a fiction version of that story in a Hollywood movie I end up taking more out of that particular story. The fact that the documentary is making the Hollywood movie more believable makes it stand out more.
The final kind of “real stories” that stand out most in my opinion, are the ones that re-live an event. An example of this is the sports documentary Dare to Dream. This was the story of the U.S Women’s soccer team. The documentary revolved around the evolution of the team, it’s three all stars, and specifically their gold medal win in 2004. What made this documentary stand out was that it was undeniably real. There was no acting and the footage was raw.
From these examples I have realized the “real world” stories that demonstrate new topics, or prove a fictional Hollywood movie right, or re-live an even seem to stand out to me the most. These types seem to be the most straightforward. They aren't trying to persuade you or win your vote over an issue. They are simply telling a story.
I think you're onto something with your last comment, Ann -- the idea of just telling a good story.
ReplyDeleteIsn't this essentially what people want with a good book or movie, a good story? I also wonder if good storytelling makes a documentary more palatable because it's seems like it's not out to convince someone or change their ideas.